
The days of our years are threescore years and ten; and if by reason of strength they be fourscore years, yet is their strength labour and sorrow; for it is soon cut off, and we fly away. —Psalm 90.10
* * *
If you live past the biblical optimum of 70 years, something in your body will give out or hurt like hell until you die.
Next month my right knee could be replaced with a man-made contraption consisting of a titanium alloy femoral cap, a titanium alloy tibial tray, a plastic spacer (a kind of shock absorber), a patellar plastic button, and bone cement (polymethyl methacrylate).
What’s not to like?
It’s obviously a material upgrade over the original. But let’s give evolution its due. Evolution took an amoeba’s pseudopodia (“false feet”) to a knee joint in just under two billion years. Given the odds and obstacles, that’s quite an achievement. The knee is awesome.
But, alas, it’s not as good as it could have been.
And that, by the way, pretty much discredits creationists’ claim of Intelligent Design. Had there been intelligence behind the design of the knee it would have opted for titanium.
Claude would have!
The surgery takes about two hours. Saws, drills, chisels, and mallets are employed.
(Think: Civil War medical tent paraphernalia. On second thought, DON’T.)
Not to worry, the surgeon tells me. You’ll be under anesthesia.
(Anesthesia, as many of you know, is the fun part of a colonoscopy.)
I’m good with anesthesia, I tell him. I’ve had nine colonoscopies. I love oblivion.
This is NOT a colonoscopy, he says. Earnestly. Forebodingly.
From what I hear, the surgery is a breeze. The rehab, however, is a bitch—excruciating pain for days and days along with mandatory therapy thrice daily for months using methods appropriated from the Spanish Inquisition.
But at least you get ice. And drugs.
It seems only yesterday I was playing basketball, racquetball, hiking steep rocky trails, and training for a marathon. In those days I’d spy old people hobbling about with a cane or walker and (1) feel sorry for them and (2) be glad I’d never need such apparatuses because I was strong, athletic, and exceptional.
You are definitely young, says my mind.
No, you aren’t, says my body. Get the knee replaced!
My heart says, Wait. Gandalf gets along fine with a walking stick.
And just like that, a walking stick sounds way better than saws, drills, chisels, bone cement, and Spanish Inquisition–inspired physical therapy.
I’m gonna give the stick a try.
And who knows, with a little luck I may become a wizard.




Perhaps it is wise to recall the final words of the Buddha: “Things fall apart. Tread the path with care.” Listening to your body is vital, especially as we age. Three years ago, I had my left knee replaced. The doctor told me it was “a matter of bone on bone”—a pretty serious matter. I have lived to tell the tale of recovery. I wish you the best as you tread your forthcoming path.
My knee was replaced more than 10 years ago and still works. Not as good as the original but very functional, nontheless. I still don’t need a cane at 84.
Not all knee replacements are torturous recoveries. We know a woman down the road who was using her walker one week and using her electric riding mower the next. No cane now and almost cleared to get back in the pool. Have faith!
Good luck with your decision Randy. To be honest, I’m a bit terrified of what you’ve described and I am hoping stem cells will create a fountain of youth in the near future. Although, I guess that’s just more my Millennial avoidance of impending mortality. That whole grace thing continues to be a mystery.
Having lived past four score & 10 years, I am grateful for the hardy & healthy part of my life… dancing & playing have slowed (a lot), but still bring me pleasure. Singing still, my range goes lower, but still brings great joy. Slowing down, but still able to walk & do yoga, my mind is slowing to a pace I can handle. This getting older comes with aches & pains (physically & otherwise). Each step chosen with care, we move forward – each choosing the best path for us. With knowledge of our choices, we get to decide what’s next. I applaud your life, your research, & your choices. And as one of my favorite tunes of late says: “We are all just walking eachother home…”. I am SO happy to be walking with you, brothers & sisters.
Thank you, Randy…”walk on…you’ll never walk alone.”
With the intelligent design of the Creator, all joints would have lasted wonderfully, but when humans make poor choices, creation is marred. Wearing out, getting sick, battling diseases long-term, corruption by pollution of the earth, and poorly managed food sources affect all of us, but I don’t blame the Creator for any of that. Humans have had choices since Eden. Though it took a lot longer to recover from knee replacement than it did from hip replacement, I am thankful to have had them done with titanium and all the other items you mentioned. In one remote province of China where I worked, they were amazed that I moved so well with artificial knees. At their hospital, joints made of wood were put in, and they didn’t work well or last long.
A hip isn’t exactly a knee, but I got mine replaced with titanium and I’m loving it. My only regret is that I didn’t get it done sooner!
And the physical therapy hasn’t been too horrible either.
Just had my right knee replaced four weeks ago and my left knee two years ago, you will have a fun ride.
It’s a bitch getting old, however we are living at an age where the medical professionals (I use that term loosely) have closets full of body parts to gives us more of a pain free ( well sorta) elder life. I must say, I had a hip replaced and, wow, what a difference, sorta. I am refraining from doing one of my favorite youthful activities….roller skating backwards at 90 mph!!
As I say to every doctor I see, I dont care about the longevity of my life, but I care a lot about the quality of my life. I know that without exercise my quality of life will crater. Two knee replacements ended the pain of walking. For that, I’m very grateful.
I hope your doctor, like mine, gives you a regimen of exercises to do for a period of time before surgery. Immensely helpful.
June Thomsen
The Creator had Cro-Magnon men in mind and designed their parts to be as durable as possible given CM people wanted to be bi-pedal. So durable for walking and occasionally chasing mammoths and avoiding saber tooths. I don’t think He envisioned (this might be heretical!) full marathons and rock climbing and break dancing. But there was that free will thing He also gave CM and so here we are, weak knees and all. Thank God, He also gave us titanium.
Good luck. I have had both knees replaced at Mercy Hospital in Baltimore many years ago. It’s a wonderful hospital and they will make a patient stay overnight, they do not release same day. They also use long acting pain drug. My first one was a challenge as I couldn’t do PT for six weeks. The second was a breeze and soon after I got home I started getting on the stairs and bending my knee gently on the upper step. I also have a stationary bike so I pushed a little on that.
Full disclosure, I fell downstairs a year ago and.broke my ankle badly, broke bones on other side, 4 hours in surgery. I had NO pain throughout, went to PT 4 times and worked at home and had full mobility in 6 months. I don’t know why I had that luck, must be doing something right.
TMI but don’t listen to people painting a grim situation of a knee replacement.
Knee replacement gets a bad rap. Do your pre surgery exercises and continue to do them after along with your rehab ones and you’ll be dancing with Paula in 2 weeks.
Bill Blair 2 new knees
Do your pre-surgery exercises, religiously ha ha ha, and continue after the surgery along with your rehab exercises and you’ll be dancing with Paula in two weeks
Wow, so many titanium knees and hips here. Makes it sound routine. If you can avoid the kind of anesthesia that requires a breathing tube, full speed ahead I would say. Medicine is a wonder and a gift.
You made me laugh! I hope you get a wizard staff, even if you have a knee replaced. I have known at least 7 knees replaced in people I know. All varied, the most recent is a friend across the hall from us…he dreaded it, but survived with flying colors, with NO pain, he says 0 pain, (he had pain with his biological knee. He says he is waiting for the other shoe to drop. It is a lot of planning, and care taker (his wife) lined up (now she might be one that needs the pain medication) and PT lined up. So, tis not easy, but he is happy to have a good excuse to watch sports on the TV all day. Good luck Randy, I’m kinda wishing you will turn into a wizard, and you can cast a spell of Kindness all over the world.
If you trust the surgeon and he says you kneed it, then you kneed it. Been there. Admittedly the recovery isn’t fun, but in time you’ll appreciate the hardware.
I had both knees upgraded, right in 2017 and left in 2023. We get by. I power walk two-three miles three days a week, fooling myself into imagining great thoughts.
Randy, you’re already a wizard. If a stick gets you out walking again, maybe even hiking gentle terrain, your leg muscles will carry the day post-surgically (as many of your readers suggest), should you change your mind! With your inability to ignore humor, how about naming the stick “Fall Staff”??? I’m sure you’ll make an inspirational duo! 🧙♂️ (Take care and keep us in the loop!)
I never realized that there was so much wisdom derived from the humble knee. Sharon did the surgery, the physical torture and is happy for it, BUT not interested in a second experience. (remember, Sharon is a retired oncologist and a certified pain educator.I know, that’s why she married me) My knees are fine, it’s just my back so I use a cane and Tylenol.
So much for our back/knee experiences that we can pass on if you need them. Re colonoscopy, I had my share and now at the wonderful age of not needing them. But my friend (the doc who did it) did tell me after my last one that I was a perfect ….. His joke, not mine.
Re my back, read Healing Back Pain. A surgeon who did over 1000 back surgeries and wrote that they are a waste of time and money. In fact, my back is slowly improving, or I’m just getting used to the pain. Whatever, no surgery for me.
Re elective surgery, never, never, never. I speak from experience. Nuff said. I have a neat cane collection.
You were asking for advice, right??????